Transformative Discourse Analysis of Urban Planning in the Era of Creative Cities: From Governance Narratives to Lived Experiences in Multicultural Contexts

Transformative Discourse Analysis of Urban Planning in the Era of Creative Cities: From Governance Narratives to Lived Experiences in Multicultural Contexts

Seyed Mohammad Rashtian1 Armin Amiri2 Mohammad Masoud3

1) Assistant Professor, Department of Urban Planning, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
2) Ph.D. Candidate in Urban Planning, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
3) Professor, Department of Architecture and Urban Planning, Isfahan University of Art, Isfahan, Iran

IOI Code : ABGG-ABKZZE
Publication : 11th.International Conference on Researches in Science & Engineering & 8th.International Congress on Civil, Architecture and Urbanism in Asia(11icrsie.ir)
Abstract :
    Abstract This study aims to examine the transformative discourse of urban planning in the era of creative cities by exploring the relationship between urban governance narratives and citizens’ lived experiences within multicultural contexts. The central research question investigates how dominant and marginal discourses are constructed within the urban planning system and how these discursive formations contribute to either fostering or constraining the realization of the creative city paradigm. The theoretical framework integrates perspectives from communicative and discursive planning theory, creative city studies, collaborative urban governance, and socio-cultural interpretations of urban development. The research adopts a qualitative approach grounded in Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA). Data were collected through a systematic examination of planning documents, policy texts, managerial reports, and both expert and local narratives. The collected data were analyzed using a three-stage coding procedure comprising open, axial, and selective coding. The findings reveal that the prevailing discourse within the urban planning system remains predominantly development-oriented, order-driven, and largely informed by technocratic and physical planning rationalities. Concepts such as economic development, infrastructure, spatial organization, and project-oriented development occupy a central position in planning documents and governance narratives. In contrast, notions including public participation, spatial justice, local identity, cultural diversity, and urban creativity, although explicitly acknowledged in policy discourse, remain largely peripheral in both policymaking and implementation. Furthermore, the results indicate that multiculturalism is represented through a dual discourse within official planning narratives: it is simultaneously framed as a valuable cultural asset and source of creative capital, while also being portrayed as a managerial challenge requiring regulation and control. At the level of lived experience, a significant discrepancy emerges between the official narratives advanced by planners and the perceptions articulated by citizens and local stakeholders. The study concludes that achieving an inclusive and genuinely creative city requires a fundamental transformation in the language, rationality, and institutional structures of urban policymaking. Such a transformation necessitates a shift toward dialogic, participatory, and culturally responsive models of urban governance capable of accommodating diversity and strengthening socially inclusive urban development.

Keywords : critical discourse analysis (cda) urban planning creative city collaborative governance multiculturalism lived experience cultural justice