From Traditional to Integrated and Adaptive Spatial Planning: Comparing Selected European Countries
From Traditional to Integrated and Adaptive Spatial Planning: Comparing Selected European Countries
somayeh ahani1 Nazanin Mirzabeigi2 Paniz Barzegar3
1) Assistant Professor, Faculty of Urban Planning, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran,
2) Student in Regional Planning, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran,
3) Student in Regional Planning, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran,
IOI Code
:
ABKD-ACZFGB
Publication :
Fourth International Conference on applied researches in civil engineering, architecture and urban planning (icarcau.com)
Abstract :
Over the past two decades, spatial planning in Europe, under the simultaneous pressure of climatic, financial and institutional challenges, has moved away from the traditional model based on land-use regulation and toward more integrated, adaptive and participatory approaches. Using a review method based on 30 scholarly sources, including large-scale European comparative studies, theoretical frameworks of resilience and spatial governance, and single-country case studies, this paper examines the course of this transition in four countries: the Netherlands, Germany, France and the United Kingdom. The findings show that the transition is neither linear nor convergent but occurs along “multiple trajectories”. The United Kingdom, whose discretionary planning system made it the most adaptive country at the beginning of the period, is now returning to a more rules-based approach. Despite extensive legal reform (the Omgevingswet), the Netherlands has in practice experienced a decline in adaptiveness. Germany remains bound to the historical weakness of its regulatory instruments, and France has simultaneously experienced two opposing processes, namely rescaling and re-centralization. These findings suggest that legal and formal integration is a necessary but not sufficient condition for a real transition to an adaptive approach in practice.
Keywords : spatial planning territorial governance policy integration adaptiveness citizen participation europe