Laughter at Any Cost: A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Performed Vulgarity Versus Artistic Comedy on Box-Office Economy and Theatre Audiences’ Cultural Taste

Laughter at Any Cost: A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Performed Vulgarity Versus Artistic Comedy on Box-Office Economy and Theatre Audiences’ Cultural Taste

Mohammad Mohsen Haerizadeh1 Seyed Mohammad Alamdar2

1) Ph.D. Candidate in Media Management, Tehran Azad University, Tehran, Iran; University Lecturer.
2) M.A. in Art Research, Islamic Azad University, Yazd, Iran.

IOI Code : ABKH-ACAFFH
Publication : 4th International Conference on Applied Researches in Humanities, Economics, Management & Accounting(icrhema.com)
Abstract :
    This article provides a comparative analysis of two contrasting paradigms of comedy in theatre: artistic comedy, which employs laughter as a tool for social critique, character development, and dramatic cohesion, and vulgarity-based performed comedy, which reduces laughter to an ultimate objective and a marketable commodity. The core problem of this study is the tension that emerges between “short-term box-office satisfaction” and “the economic and cultural sustainability of the theatre industry.” The theoretical framework is grounded in the synthesis of three traditions: the sociology of laughter and its social function, drawing upon Bergson; Adorno and Horkheimer’s critique of the culture industry to explain the commercialization of laughter; and Bourdieu’s theory of cultural capital and taste to account for differences in audience choices. Subsequently, six operational dramatic indicators—plot-driven versus joke-driven structure, the function of laughter, the ratio of body and speech to situation, audience pattern, box-office sustainability, and reflective impact—are formulated to distinguish the two poles of this spectrum. Evidence from the commercial theatre market indicates that high sales do not necessarily signify the structural health of the industry: based on official reports, the 2024–2025 Broadway season set a historical record with $1.89 billion in sales and 14.7 million patrons, yet the following season experienced a decline in attendance (14,577,322 patrons) and seating capacity percentage (90.8%) despite a 1% increase in revenue to $1.91 billion. This fluctuation reinforces the hypothesis of “price inflation rather than audience expansion.” Finally, the paper proposes a three-layered conceptual model that delineates the position of performed vulgarity, artistic comedy, and the institutional linkages among production, media, and cultural policymaking.

Keywords : artistic comedy performed vulgarity theatre economy culture industry cultural capital audience taste box office sustainability