Employee Motivation Interventions and Project Performance: The Role of Management Structure and Organizational Context

Employee Motivation Interventions and Project Performance: The Role of Management Structure and Organizational Context

Amin Kamaei1 Hamed Karimi2 Mehran Derakhshandeh3 Kiarash Naseri4

1) Project Portfolio Supervisor of Shahre Babak Copper Complex National Iranian Copper Industrial Development & Engineering Co. -
2) PMO Manager National Iranian Copper Industrial Development & Engineering Co. -
3) Senior Planning and Project Control Engineer National Iranian Copper Industrial Development & Engineering Co. -
4) Planning and Project Control Expert National Iranian Copper Industrial Development & Engineering Co. -

IOI Code : ACCD-ACAZBH
Publication : 10th International Conference on Applied Researches in Science & Engineering (carseconf.com)
Abstract :
    Managerial interventions aimed at enhancing employee motivation can lead to improved project performance when they are aligned not only with employees’ motivational needs but also with the project’s operational conditions and organizational characteristics. This study aims to examine changes in employee motivation and the extent of monthly plan achievement following the implementation of motivation-oriented managerial interventions, and to explain differences in outcomes across projects with different scopes. Methodologically, the study adopts a quantitative approach and a multiple-case longitudinal design involving three industrial projects: the Khatoonabad Lime Plant, the Khatoonabad Slag Flotation Project, and the Miduk Phase II Concentrator Project. In each project, the motivation of 12 employees was assessed at two time points, before and after the implementation of managerial interventions, focusing on three dimensions—autonomy, competence, and relatedness—based on self-determination theory. In addition, monthly plan achievement before and after the intervention was compared using the ratio of actual performance to the achievable monthly target. The results showed that the mean scores for all three motivational dimensions increased across all three projects, although the increase in motivation was greater in the Khatoonabad Lime Plant Project than in the other two projects. Regarding monthly plan achievement, average performance increased from 44.11% to 73.09% in the Khatoonabad Lime Plant Project, from 36.02% to 41.40% in the Khatoonabad Slag Flotation Project, and from 41.01% to 42.75% in the Miduk Phase II Concentrator Project. Exploratory statistical comparisons of the pre- and post-intervention periods indicated a statistically significant increase in this indicator in the two Khatoonabad projects. In contrast, the observed change in the Miduk Phase II Concentrator Project was not statistically significant at the adjusted significance level. Overall, the findings indicate that increased employee motivation does not necessarily translate into a commensurate improvement in monthly plan achievement. Accordingly, the alignment of the project’s management structure—particularly the way responsibilities are divided between the Project Manager and the Construction Manager—is proposed as a managerial and contextual explanation to be investigated in future research. However, the present study did not directly test the causal effect of organizational structure on differences in project performance.

Keywords : employee motivation self determination theory monthly plan achievement project management construction manager project organizational structure