A Comparative Study of the Deterrent Effect of Punishments for Drug Possession and Carrying Offenses under the Laws of Iran, Portugal, and Norway
A Comparative Study of the Deterrent Effect of Punishments for Drug Possession and Carrying Offenses under the Laws of Iran, Portugal, and Norway
akbar nasr esfahani1 mojtaba farahmand2
1) Graduate in Criminal Law and Criminology, Faculty of Islamic Governance, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan,
2) Assistant Professor of Criminal Law and Criminology, Faculty of Islamic Governance, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan,
IOI Code
:
ACZF-ACACHA
Publication :
6th.International Congress on Management, Economy, Humanities, Education and Business Development(6icmba.ir)
Abstract :
The criminal policy of nations regarding narcotics oscillates between two poles: a health-oriented intervention approach and penal repression. The issue of narcotics—and the reduction of their consumption through the application of penalties such as fines, flogging, imprisonment, asset forfeiture, and the death penalty—remains a central topic of debate among legal scholars. Specifically, the possession and carrying of narcotics, and the role of punitive deterrence in preventing recidivism, represent a significant challenge in contemporary society; consequently, legislators are constantly seeking effective strategies to lower the incidence of these offenses. This study employs a descriptive-analytical methodology to conduct a comparative examination of three legal systems. The findings indicate that in Iran, despite the legislator’s imposition of stringent penalties for drug-related offenses, the high number of drug-related executions suggests that a purely repressive policy has failed to achieve a sustainable reduction in crime. Furthermore, the fines stipulated under Articles 4 and 8 of the Anti-Narcotics Law—due to a lack of alignment with the offenders financial capacity, the impact of inflation, and an insufficient link to treatment—have proven limited in preventing recidivism. Conversely, the experience of Portugal demonstrates that decriminalizing the consumption and possession of small quantities—when coupled with treatment and harm-reduction measures—can improve public health indicators and reduce the incarceration of individuals struggling with addiction. Similarly, the Norwegian model suggests that ensuring the proportionality of punishment and focusing efforts on trafficking and supply is more effective than intensifying penalties for individual consumers. Accordingly, an optimal criminal policy should be a combination of proportionate punishment, treatment, prevention, and harm reduction.
Keywords : deterrence monetary fine carrying and possession law narcotics