Freedom of Expression in Contemporary Human Rights and Its Limitations in Islamic Legal Systems

Freedom of Expression in Contemporary Human Rights and Its Limitations in Islamic Legal Systems

Fatemeh Goodarzi1 Najmeh Darenjani Shirazi2

1) Bachelor of Law, Marvdasht Branch, Islamic Azad University, Marvdasht, Iran.
2) Doctor of Law, Private Practice, Yasuj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Yasuj, Iran. (Lecturer, Azad University).

IOI Code : AZDD-AAFHHC
Publication : 4th.International Congress on Management, Economy, Humanities and Business Development(4icmba.ir)
Abstract :
    Freedom of expression, as one of the fundamental pillars of human rights, not only plays a central role in shaping political and social life, but is also an important indicator for measuring the level of democracy and the rule of law in any society. In international documents such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, this right has an absolute-relative position and can only be limited in specific limited circumstances. However, in Islamic legal systems, freedom of expression is always defined within the framework of Sharia and its purposes, which sometimes leads to conflict with international standards. The main purpose of this research is to conduct a comparative study of the foundations and scope of freedom of expression in contemporary human rights and Islamic legal systems, analyze examples of restrictions in selected countries, and identify challenges and points of conflict in order to provide practical solutions for convergence or reduction of tensions. This research was conducted using a descriptive-analytical method and using a library study. Sources include international human rights instruments, fatwas and jurisprudential texts, constitutional and criminal laws of Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan, and related scientific-research articles. A comparative approach was used in data analysis to extract conceptual, legal, and executive commonalities and differences. The findings show that in the international system, restrictions on freedom of expression are subject to three criteria: legality, legitimacy, and necessity, while Islamic systems add a fourth criterion: compliance with Sharia. This results in broader restrictions in areas such as insulting sacred places, spreading lies, propaganda against religious values, and incitement to corruption. The comparative study showed that Iran uses a dual codified model (Shariah + governmental), Saudi Arabia uses a traditional system based on judicial ijtihad and texts, and Pakistan uses a mixed common law-Sharia model. Also, different understandings of the concept of public morality are the source of many interpretative differences. The conflict between the universality of human rights and cultural-religious relativism in the area of freedom of expression remains unresolved after decades of negotiation. However, solutions such as strengthening intercultural dialogue, ijtihadist rereading of Islamic texts, clarification of laws, and public legal education can pave the way for convergence.

Keywords : freedom of expression contemporary human rights islamic legal systems sharia restrictions cultural relativism sharia objectives