Agile Governance of Civil and Criminal Liability for Emerging AI Technologies
Agile Governance of Civil and Criminal Liability for Emerging AI Technologies
Mohsen Haghi1 Seyyed Abbas Hosseini2 Sara Sepahbod Bakhshayesh3 Parisa ShiroudHeydari4 Mohaddeseh Amiri5 Sahar Mohammadi6 Hamed Irani Asl7
1) Master s student in Commercial companies Law at the University of Judicial Sciences and Administrative Services of the Judiciary, Tehran –
2) Official teacher at the Ministry of Education, Senior Editor at the Cafe Bazaar and Bimeh Bazaar platforms, and researcher in the field of video games and information and communication technology –
3) M.A. in Communication Law from Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran –
4) Master s student in International Trade Law at the Faculty of Farabi, University of Tehran –
5) M.A. in Judicial Administration from the University of Judicial Sciences and Administrative Services of the Judiciary, Tehran –
6) LL.B. from the University of Tehran –
7) Master s student in Criminal Law and Criminology at Islamic Azad University, Ardabil –
IOI Code
:
AZGA-AAEGEG
Publication :
5th International Conference on Advanced Research in Management And Humanities(huconf.com/5th)
Abstract :
The accelerating expansion and deployment of Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems as a new paradigm has posed an unprecedented challenge to the theoretical foundations of classical criminal law, particularly the concepts of volition and mens rea . Aiming to propose an Agile Governance framework to address this challenge, this research analyzes and evaluates the criminal liability arising from the actions of intelligent technologies. Employing a normative-analytical method and a comparative approach, this paper meticulously examines the positive law of Indonesia, alongside the regulatory experiences of the European Union, the United States, China, Japan, and the legislative gaps in Iran. The central research question is how, in the absence of criminal capacity for Artificial Intelligence, an efficient, just, and deterrent accountability system can be designed.The findings indicate that the direct attribution of criminal liability to Artificial Intelligence as an independent agent is doctrinally impossible and practically futile. Instead, this research proposes a multi-faceted model of human accountability across the AI value chain . This model transcends traditional patterns of indirect liability to include novel concepts such as Criminal Negligence in Design and Development , the Doctrine of Responsible Command for the operators of autonomous systems, and procedural innovations like the Reversal of the Burden of Proof in so-called black box cases to ensure transparency. Ultimately, the research concludes that effectively addressing the legal challenges of AI requires a transition from static, reactive laws towards a dynamic, preventive, and adaptive governance ecosystem that can guarantee responsible innovation within a framework of transparency, justice, and accountability.
Keywords : artificial intelligence criminal liability agile governance responsible command negligence in design