The Stabilisation Paradox in Hot-Arid Earthen Architecture
The Stabilisation Paradox in Hot-Arid Earthen Architecture
Amin Dastmardi1 Amir Dastmardi2
1) Master of Architecture ,Faculty of Art and Architecture, Islamic Azad University, Yazd Branch, Yazd, Iran -
2) Assistant Professor, School of Visual Arts, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran , Iran -
IOI Code
:
ABKD-ABHHDD
Publication :
Fourth International Conference on applied researches in civil engineering, architecture and urban planning (icarcau.com)
Abstract :
Unfired earthen materials — adobe, rammed earth, and compressed earth blocks — carry among the lowest embodied-carbon footprints of any structural walling system, a property that matters most precisely where it is least exploited: in hot-arid regions facing both rapid construction growth and mounting pressure to decarbonise. Yet raw earth has real limitations. Moisture erosion, variable compressive strength, and code-compliance requirements routinely push designers toward stabilising it with Portland cement, and this is where the trouble starts: the same intervention that makes earthen walls structurally acceptable also erodes the environmental case for building with earth in the first place. This paper synthesises evidence from seven peer-reviewed life cycle assessment studies to size this trade-off precisely. The pattern is stark. Adding 8–10% cement by mass raises the embodied carbon of rammed earth from a baseline of 25–35 kgCO₂/m³ to 140–200 kgCO₂/m³, a four-to-six-fold increase that a separate, independent review of 132 studies confirms in relative terms. At that stabilisation level, rammed earth no longer outperforms ordinary fired clay brick on carbon — it simply becomes another masonry option. Recent work from Egypt and Australia points toward a way out: construction and demolition waste, calcium oxide, and natural fibre reinforcement can deliver comparable structural performance without the same carbon penalty. The paper argues that building codes in hot-arid regions, by specifying compressive strength without recognising these alternatives, default designers into the most carbon-intensive stabilisation pathway available, and closes with recommendations for performance-based code reform and further research on low-carbon binders.
Keywords : earthen architecture embodied carbon stabilisation life cycle assessment hot arid climate