Beyond Form: Rethinking the Role of Physical, Social, and Institutional Variables in the Success and Failure of Mass Housing Projects: A Critical Review of the Pruitt-Igoe and Mehr Housing Experiences
Beyond Form: Rethinking the Role of Physical, Social, and Institutional Variables in the Success and Failure of Mass Housing Projects: A Critical Review of the Pruitt-Igoe and Mehr Housing Experiences
Akbar Norouzi1
1) Ph.D. in Urban Planning, Department of Urban Planning, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch, Qazvin, Iran
IOI Code
:
AACZ-ABGFBB
Publication :
The 5th International Conference on Seismic Retrofitting(5icst.ir)
Abstract :
Abstract
Introduction and Research Necessity: Mass housing projects, as one of the most critical instruments of state intervention in housing provision, have consistently remained at the center of theoretical and empirical debates in urban planning. In this context, the demolition of the Pruitt-Igoe housing complex in the United States has been widely cited in urban studies as a paradigmatic example of the failure of certain modernist mass housing models. Conversely, the Mehr Housing scheme in Iran, despite sharing certain physical similarities with modernist mass housing paradigms, has followed a divergent trajectory, frequently resulting in sustained habitation. This divergence in the outcomes of these two experiences underscores the necessity of rethinking the role of physical attributes and examining the contribution of social, economic, and institutional variables to the success or failure of mass housing projects.
Aim and Research Method: The present study aims to critically analyze the factors influencing the fate of mass housing projects and to critique the physical determinism approach prevalent in certain strands of urban planning literature. In terms of objective, this research is fundamental, and methodologically, it is qualitative, relying on a critical literature review. The required data were collected through the examination of scientific sources, policy documents, academic research, and reports related to the Pruitt-Igoe experience and the Mehr Housing scheme, and were subsequently analyzed using a comparative-interpretive approach.
Research Scope: The thematic scope of the research encompasses the examination of a set of physical, social, economic, managerial, and institutional factors affecting the performance of mass housing projects. Its spatial scope covers two prominent case studies: the Pruitt-Igoe project in St. Louis, USA, and the Mehr Housing scheme in Iran.
Findings: The research findings indicate that although certain physical characteristics, such as building density, repetitive construction patterns, and large-scale development, are observable in both experiences, non-physical factors have played a more decisive role in shaping the final outcomes. In the Pruitt-Igoe experience, the concentration of poverty, urban economic decline, deficiencies in management and maintenance systems, and the erosion of social capital were critical factors contributing to the project s decline and failure. Conversely, in the Mehr Housing experience, the expansion of individual homeownership, the presence of kinship and social networks, sustained housing demand, and continuous state intervention in infrastructure provision have contributed to the continuation of habitation and the relative sustainability of these projects.
Conclusion: The results demonstrate that explaining the success or failure of mass housing projects solely based on physical characteristics is a reductionist and inadequate approach. The fate of these projects is the result of the complex interaction of social, economic, institutional, and managerial variables alongside physical attributes. Accordingly, this study emphasizes the necessity of transitioning from purely physical-centric approaches to multi-dimensional and institutional analytical frameworks in the planning, policymaking, and evaluation of mass housing projects.
Keywords : mass housing pruitt igoe mehr housing physical determinism urban governance social capital housing policy urban planning