Legal analysis of civil liability arising from artificial intelligence in electronic contracts with a comparative approach to Iranian and European Union law

Legal analysis of civil liability arising from artificial intelligence in electronic contracts with a comparative approach to Iranian and European Union law

Hamidreza mirsoleymani1

1) Master of Laws, Private Law Major, Islamic Azad University, Safashar Branch, Fars, Iran

IOI Code : AAHD-ABKGZZ
Publication : National Conference on Information Technology, Nanotechnology, Artificial Intelligence and Technological Futures Studies(itnaf.ir)
Abstract :
    increasing application in the process of concluding, interpreting, and enforcing electronic contracts have presented legal systems with unprecedented challenges in the field of civil liability. Features such as relative autonomy, algorithmic, and continuous learning capabilities have posed serious difficulties to the traditional attribution of fault and establishing causality. The present article, using a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach, examines the foundations, pillars, and challenges of civil liability arising from the operation of artificial intelligence in electronic contracts in the two legal systems of Iran and the European Union. The findings show that in Iranian law, despite the capacities available in the general rules of civil liability (such as the rule of loss, attribution, and the theory of non-action), there is a clear legislative vacuum in the field of specific regulations for artificial intelligence, and the traditional fault-based system does not respond to the complexities of autonomous technologies. In contrast, the European Union, by adopting the AI ​​regulation and revising the Product Liability Directive, has designed a dual framework based on strict liability for producers and facilitated fault-based liability for operators of high-risk systems. However, this framework is mainly focused on non-contractual liability, and the gap in specific rules in the area of ​​contractual liability arising from AI still persists. Finally, inspired by the EU approach and relying on the capacities of Imami jurisprudence and Iranian statutory law, the article offers solutions for the Iranian legal system, including the development of specific regulations based on a risk-based approach, the reversal of the burden of proof in high-risk systems, the establishment of joint and several liability between the producer and the operator, and the requirement for mandatory insurance.

Keywords : civil liability artificial intelligence electronic contracts iranian law european union artificial intelligence regulations strict liability fault based liability