Comparative Analysis of Criminal Liability of Legal Entities in Cybercrimes with an Approach to the Legal Systems of Iran and the European Union
Comparative Analysis of Criminal Liability of Legal Entities in Cybercrimes with an Approach to the Legal Systems of Iran and the European Union
Amir chaman1
1) Senior Professor of Criminal Law and Criminology, Lahijan Azad University
IOI Code
:
AAHF-ACZZZD
Publication :
National Conference on Architecture and Art Technologies, Smart City, Soft and Creative Industries and Technological Culture(icact.ir)
Abstract :
The expansion of organizations dependence on digital infrastructure, outsourcing of technology services, cloud computing, and software supply chains has led to legal entities not only being victims, but also, in some situations, being the platform, beneficiary, or even organizer of cybercrime. The present study, using a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach, examines the criteria for attributing criminal liability to legal entities in Iranian law and the legal framework of the European Union. In Iran, Article 143 of the Islamic Penal Code has based the general rule of legal entity liability on the commission of a crime by the legal representative in the name or in the interests of the legal entity; In the field of computer crimes, Article 19 of the Computer Crimes Law, reflected in Article 747 of the Fifth Book of Penal Code, establishes four specific assumptions, including commission by a manager, an order from a manager, commission by an employee with the knowledge of the manager or resulting from lack of supervision, and dedication of all or part of the activity of a legal entity to computer crime. In the European Union, Directive 2013/40/EU and Directive 2019/713 have established the dual model of “person in a leadership position” and “lack of supervision or control” for the liability of legal entities; in addition, NIS2, DORA, and the Cyber Resilience Act have expanded the logic of organizational liability from post-crime response to proactive governance and board accountability. The findings show that Iranian law has a clear foundation in terms of stipulating the criminal liability of legal entities for cybercrimes, but it faces shortcomings in defining the lack of supervision, the position of compliance programs, measuring organizational fault, liability in corporate group structures, and the scalability of performance guarantees. In contrast, the European Union system, although it does not create a uniform and centralized criminal liability for all member states, has moved towards a model of “organization-based and compliance liability” through minimum standards, liability arising from lack of supervision, deterrent fines, and cyber governance requirements. The article suggests that the Iranian legislator, while maintaining the structure of Article 747, explicitly introduce the criteria of organizational fault, defense or mitigation based on an effective compliance program, fines commensurate with turnover, and special requirements for senior managers in cyber risk management into the liability system of legal entities.
Keywords : criminal liability of legal entities cybercrimes computer crimes organizational fault