Comparative assessment of urban planning indicators in Copenhagen, Dakar, and Tehran: sustainability, spatial justice, and urban governance
Comparative assessment of urban planning indicators in Copenhagen, Dakar, and Tehran: sustainability, spatial justice, and urban governance
Akbar Norouzi1
1) Ph.D. in Urban Planning, Department of Urban Planning, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch
IOI Code
:
ABFG-ACAAZK
Publication :
12th.international Congress on Civil Engineering, Architecture, Art and Urban Development(12icsau.ir)
Abstract :
Abstract:
Introduction and significance: Global urban liveability indices reveal deep divides between cities of the Global North and Global South. However, reliance solely on these aggregate rankings—without interrogating the structural and institutional mechanisms that produce such inequalities—not only fails to provide solutions but also marginalizes the lived experiences of residents in the Global South. Understanding the causes of this divergence requires moving beyond a simple North/South dichotomy and analyzing governance capacities across different contexts.
Research objective: This study offers a comparative, mechanism-focused assessment of key urban planning indicators in three cities—Copenhagen, Tehran, and Dakar—to explain their divergence in global liveability rankings and to critique the effectiveness of these indicators in representing urban realities and residents’ lived experiences.
Scope: The research uses a descriptive-analytical method and a multiple-case comparative design. The spatial scope includes Copenhagen (representing high institutional capacity), Tehran (a metropolis with structural challenges and institutional instability), and Dakar (a capital facing climate vulnerability and a large informal economy). Data were drawn from reputable secondary sources, including the Economist Intelligence Unit’s Liveability Index (2025–2026), official city reports, and peer-reviewed articles from 2020 to 2026, and were analyzed within a five-dimension conceptual model.
Findings: Results indicate that Copenhagen (score: 98) achieves the highest quality of life due to institutional stability and long-term planning, although it experiences hidden ecological inequalities at the neighborhood level. In contrast, Tehran (rank: 164) faces the paradox of accumulated technical knowledge but poor institutional capacity, producing acute spatial inequalities. Dakar (rank: 171) follows a third trajectory characterized by climate vulnerability, where grassroots institutional innovations confront structural weaknesses and resource scarcity.
Discussion and conclusion: The liveability gap among these three cities stems less from geographic location or income level than from governance capacity and a justice-oriented planning approach. Moreover, aggregate global indices obscure intra-urban inequalities and thus present a misleading picture of liveability. Finally, transitions toward liveable cities in the Global South require redesigning measurement indicators to emphasize spatial distribution and the lived experiences of marginalized populations, alongside strengthening climate resilience and networked governance.
Keywords : comparative evaluation of urban livability spatial justice and urban governance in copenhagen tehran dakar