Ancient Origins of Zoning: A Comparative Analysis of Functional Land-Use Separation in Shahr-e Sukhteh and the Zoning Theory of Reinhard Baumeister
Ancient Origins of Zoning: A Comparative Analysis of Functional Land-Use Separation in Shahr-e Sukhteh and the Zoning Theory of Reinhard Baumeister
نوروزی1
1) Ph.D. in Urban Planning, Department of Urban Planning, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch
IOI Code
:
ABKD-ACZAEG
Publication :
Fourth International Conference on applied researches in civil engineering, architecture and urban planning (icarcau.com)
Abstract :
Abstract
In mainstream urban planning literature, zoning is predominantly recognized as a modern construct emerging from the Industrial Revolution and a response to the public health crises of the 19th century. This Eurocentric narrative has marginalized the ancient roots of the logic underlying land-use segregation. The significance of this research lies in a genealogical re-reading of the concept of zoning and the uncovering of the underlying rationale governing spatial organization in ancient civilizations. Adopting a comparative-interpretive approach and employing morphological analysis, this study investigates a twofold domain of inquiry: first, the spatial organization of Shahr-e Sukhteh (3rd millennium BCE) as one of the earliest instances of planned urbanism on the Iranian Plateau; and second, Reinhard Baumeister’s sanitary zoning theory within the 1876 Berlin Master Plan. The findings reveal that, despite the temporal and cultural distance between the two contexts, a shared environmental logic governed the segregation of noxious land uses from sensitive ones. The discussion demonstrates that the fundamental difference between the two paradigms lies not in the principle of segregation itself, but in the source of its rationale ; in Shahr-e Sukhteh, the logic of land-use segregation was rooted in environmental determinism and lived experiences, whereas in Baumeister’s theory, this logic evolved into a deliberate legal and public health instrument.
Keywords : zoning land use segregation shahr e sukhteh reinhard baumeister urban morphology urban archaeology